Black (Cyber) Monday: How the Sausage is Made in an Instantaneous, Digital World
How I Felt Ridiculous When I Ordered Same-Day Delivery
In this short bonus episode, I briefly examine the complexities of modern consumerism and the often-overlooked hidden costs of our convenience-driven shopping habits. As we rush into another holiday shopping season, I revisit a 2018 article that explored the darker side of online shopping convenience, particularly during events like Cyber Monday.
The rapid evolution of retail and escalating consumer expectations, from the demand for same-day delivery to the profound human cost on logistics and fulfillment workers, present a stark reality.
We’ll hear poignant accounts from industry workers, revealing the grim conditions that often go unnoticed as we click “buy now." As consumers, our knowledge and awareness empower us to make conscious decisions about what, where, and how we shop.
Takeaways:
- The rapid convenience of online shopping has hidden costs, both financial and ethical, that we need to acknowledge.
- Witnessing the human toll behind instantaneous deliveries can change our perspective on what convenience really costs us.
- As consumers, we have the power to reshape expectations and demand better working conditions for retail workers.
- The dark side of e-commerce reveals uncomfortable truths about logistics and labor that are often overlooked.
- With increased awareness, we can make informed decisions about our consumption habits and their broader impacts.
Resources:
- New York Times: The Daily Podcast: The Human Toll of Instant Delivery
- The Nation: Amazon’s Prime Sweatshop Is Nothing to Celebrate
- Original article in Medium
- GlobalWarmingIsReal.com
Welcome to this bonus episode of the soon to be renamed Global Warming Is Real podcast.
Speaker AAs we embark on another consumerist holiday feeding frenzy, I'm revisiting an article I wrote for medium back in 2018.
Speaker AWith all the convenience of online shopping, especially with Cypra Monday again upon us, I explore the hidden cost of all this convenience.
Speaker AOften for things we don't need or even want that much, enjoy this retelling of Black how the Sausage is Made in an Instantaneous Digital World One of the benefits I once enjoyed when I had an Amazon prime membership was speedy delivery.
Speaker APretty much anything I wanted I could find online and have it delivered the next morning.
Speaker ASometimes the same day.
Speaker AThough I can't remember what it was I thought I needed so urgently, I do remember ordering something for same day delivery.
Speaker AIt arrived at 9:30pm that evening by a bedraggled man looking as if he'd been delivering crap to people's houses since the night before.
Speaker AWhatever it is I ordered, it sat in my office until the next day.
Speaker AI am as accustomed as the next person living in urban America to the disruption in retail wrought by Amazon.
Speaker AI can intellectualize the process, but it is too easy to leave it there, just an abstraction.
Speaker AOnly that one time, ordering same day delivery for whatever, that I get a real sense of the true cost of the business model.
Speaker ASeeing the guy that night delivering something I didn't eat all that much, certainly not that night pulled it out of my head and into my gut just a little bit.
Speaker AIn the Human Toll of Instant Delivery, the New York Times highlights the reporting of NYT business journalist Jessica Silver Greenberg on the explosive growth of retail shopping logistics services.
Speaker ACompanies like XPO Logistics are both the result and facilitator of the new retail Amazon has primed the pump of consumer expectation, forcing others to compete in an unfamiliar landscape or fold up their tent and go home.
Speaker AEven if that tent has been around for decades.
Speaker AFrom a consumer perspective, it just kind of happened.
Speaker ALike iPhones or Uber or Facebook or the waste heap called X.
Speaker AAnd now AI.
Speaker AIt all happened so fast.
Speaker AOf course, it didn't just happen.
Speaker AWith varying degrees of specificity and motivation, smart people laid out brilliant plans to achieve their vision.
Speaker AIn this context, vision implies seeing what others don't see, an expanded view of what can be.
Speaker AIndeed, few fully anticipated the hyperconnected, instantaneous, nonstop AI driven world we inhabit today.
Speaker AVisionary minds have carried us here, but as the New York Times reports, at what cost?
Speaker AOne of the great human foibles among many is our ability to constantly outwit ourselves.
Speaker AThe spark of human imagination, curiosity and creativity can soar to great heights, but often too high, too fast, and for the wrong reasons.
Speaker AEven the visionaries among us can't see far enough.
Speaker AIn a sense, it did all just happen.
Speaker AVision does not necessarily imply wisdom.
Speaker AWe have yet to master fully the ability to understand the consequences of what is unleashed from the human mind.
Speaker AAnd what of the the Working Conditions for XPO Logistics Employees Tasha Murrell, a former employee at an XBO warehouse in Memphis, tells Michael Barbaro of the New York Times about being forced to take off abroad to get through security, only then to be constantly ogled and harassed by her male co workers working in extreme temperatures for long hours and not knowing when the shift will end.
Speaker AShe speaks of supervisors ignoring her doctor's instructions after she became pregnant, of being told to have a fucking abortion after asking to go home one day because she wasn't feeling well that night.
Speaker AShe miscarried her child, one of five women who suffered miscarriages in as many months they all worked in the same XPO warehouse in Memphis.
Speaker AShe talks of the day a co worker collapsed and died of a heart attack on the production floor after complaining for hours that she didn't feel well of being told to continue working around the woman's dead body, which lay there for hours.
Speaker AEven if we are eager or forced participants of Amazon style e commerce, as I surely have been and still am, this isn't the way we want it to be, is it?
Speaker AWe click on whatever we want, expecting a clean cut young man or woman in a crisp uniform to deliver it to our door.
Speaker APackage delivery is not inherently bad, but there is more to the picture than meets the eye.
Speaker AA dark underbelly.
Speaker AIt's where the sausage is made.
Speaker AWe best know about it no matter how or if it changes our behavior.
Speaker AIn a consumerist society with nearly every detail of our individual lives mapped, analyzed, demographied and delivered to any paying customer, consumption is where much, most or all of our power lies.
Speaker AIf a woman can lie dead on a production floor for hours while her distraught co workers are forced to work around her in order to satisfy consumer expectations, then consumers need to take control of what those expectations are.
Speaker AAnyway.
Speaker AIt's something to think about.
Speaker AThanks for joining me on this lightly edited narration of Black how the Sausage is Made in an instantaneous digital world.
Speaker AThe takeaway for me is that with awareness and reflection we can make more informed decisions about what, how and where we buy.
Speaker AWhen you can think small.
Speaker ACheck the show notes for more information on working conditions at Amazon Fulfillment Centers.
Speaker AThere's a link to listen to the New York Times podcast referenced in the article or read the original piece published in Medium.
Speaker AIf you like what we're doing, please like and subscribe to the podcast.
Speaker AAnd if you can spare a dollar or two, feel free to leave a tip to help keep us going.
Speaker AWe would definitely appreciate that.
Speaker AThanks for listening and we'll see you next time on the soon to be renamed Global Warming Is Real.
Speaker AAnd that's not to say that global warming is not real.
Speaker ABut we'll see you next time.
Speaker ATake care.
Speaker AThere's always more we can do to stop climate change.
Speaker ANo amount of engagement is too little.
Speaker AAnd now more than ever, your involvement matters.
Speaker ATo learn more and do more, visit globalwarmingisreal.com thanks for listening.
Speaker AI'm your host, Tom Schueneman.
Speaker AWe'll see you next time on Global Warming Is Real.