Sustainability Isn't a Dirty Word: A Conversation With Sustainable Business Expert Lee Stewart
The 1970s “Crying Indian” campaign, as it came to be known, with its poignant imagery and simple message about littering, has left an indelible mark on American culture.
Yet, as we unpack the history and implications of this campaign, we discover that not all was as it appeared.
It served as a brilliant marketing tactic by corporations to shift the onus of pollution onto individuals, effectively masking the real environmental damage caused by corporate practices. The origins of the Keep America Beautiful campaign reveal how it was strategically designed to deflect attention from industry-generated pollution and place the blame squarely on consumers.
The campaign highlights the pernicious nature of greenwashing and its evolution into the modern business landscape, where companies often prioritize image over genuine environmental responsibility. Our guest, Lee Stewart, is the author of How to Build Sustainability Into Your Business Strategy: A Practical No-Nonsense Guide for Business Leaders.
His work and book provide insight into how businesses can navigate this complex terrain. He emphasizes the need to shift from superficial sustainability claims to authentic action.
Drawing from his extensive experience across various industries, Lee outlines practical steps for integrating sustainability into business operations. He advocates for a triple bottom line approach, where profit, people, and planet are equally prioritized, and urges business leaders to engage their teams in meaningful conversations about sustainability.
Takeaways:
- The iconic Crying Indian ad, while effective in reducing litter, also shifted blame onto individuals, diverting attention from corporate pollution.
- Cody Iron Eyes, the face of the ad, wasn’t actually Native American, raising questions about authenticity in environmental messaging.
- Authentic sustainability efforts must focus on systemic change rather than merely reducing individual litter, or they risk becoming greenwashing.
- Lee Stewart advocates for actionable sustainability strategies that genuinely engage businesses to create long-term environmental benefits.
- A robust sustainability strategy involves understanding the business’s impact, engaging employees, and aligning with customer expectations for a competitive edge.
- The call for transparency in sustainability practices is growing, with frameworks, like Lee Stewart’s Triple C framework, requiring companies to disclose their carbon emissions and environmental impacts.
Resources:
- Lee Stewart Book, Bio, Media, and Press
- Cody Iron Eyes and Keep America Beautiful
- Global Warming is Real
00:00 - Untitled
00:12 - The Impact of Public Service Announcements
02:49 - The Evolution of Greenwashing and Authentic Sustainability
13:57 - The Evolution of Sustainability in Corporate Practices
30:03 - Creating a Circular Economy in Tonga
33:46 - The Role of AI in Sustainability
If you're old enough, you might remember Cody Iron Eyes, the iconic Native American who appeared in an equally iconic TV public service announcement.
Speaker AStanding by the side of the road, a car rushes by as a hand thrusts trees through its open window, landing at Cody's feet.
Speaker AHe looks up as the camera closes in on a single tear streaking down his cheek.
Speaker AThe Crying Indian, as the bit came to be known, seared its way into the console televisions racing the shag carpeted living rooms of the 1970s, reminding us not to litter and to keep America beautiful.
Speaker AThe message seems straightforward enough.
Speaker AIndeed, for decades after its airing, I thought it was.
Speaker AI took its message to heart.
Speaker APeople cause pollution.
Speaker APeople can stop it.
Speaker ABut all was not as it appeared.
Speaker ATo begin with, Cody Iron Eyes was not a Native American, though he apparently portrayed himself as one throughout his career in TV and movies.
Speaker AHis immigrant heritage came across the sea from Italy.
Speaker AThe ad presumably appealed to environmental stewardship and was produced by the non profit Keep America Beautiful and the Business Friendly Ad Council.
Speaker AKeep America Beautiful is still around in its website.
Speaker AIt's all the right buttons.
Speaker AIt has its origins in the early 1950s, founded by the American Can Company, Owens Illinois Glass Company and later by Coca Cola.
Speaker AWith the growth of post war boomer town consumption and single use convenience, big business saw the writing on the wall.
Speaker AToo much attention on the expanding effluent of their operations, means, regulations and public scrutiny.
Speaker ABetter to remind the bleeding heart public of their own responsibility.
Speaker APeople start pollution, people can stop it.
Speaker AThe ad worked on all levels.
Speaker AWe felt the pain of Cody ironize.
Speaker AHis tear and roadside litter did in fact decrease.
Speaker AAnd the consumer goods sector learned to deftly shift responsibility for the ravages of unrestrained industry on individuals and consumers who face a daily barrage of advertising that entices them to consume more.
Speaker AA vicious circle feeding the machine.
Speaker AIt was arguably the birth of greenwashing, or at least one aspect of it.
Speaker AKeep America Beautiful's internal documents and industry messaging make clear that the campaign's fundamental objective was to, and I quote, generalize responsibility and universalize guilt.
Speaker AClassic hallmarks of greenwashing.
Speaker AAll these years later, the circumstances have changed, particularly in our supercharged misinformation juggernaut.
Speaker ABut the song remains the same, a playbook rooted in opaque motivations, deceptions, distractions and untruths.
Speaker AAh, but we must not succumb to cynicism despite decades of misdirection.
Speaker AThat's the ultimate danger of modern greenwashing.
Speaker AWe know it's there and thus assume.
Speaker BThat any talk of sustainable business is.
Speaker ABS and given what I've just described, it's understandable.
Speaker ABut it's not the whole story.
Speaker AWe live in a decidedly non black and white world and blame shifting feeds this us, them either or mindset to the point of Keep America Beautiful's psa.
Speaker AIf reducing roadside litter distracts from systemic changes, then pollution and unsustainable patterns of production and consumption continue even with less litter.
Speaker AAll this makes the work that much more challenging and urgent for an authentic effort to guide businesses big and small to take their environmental and social responsibility seriously and communicate that effort transparently.
Speaker AIf you look closely enough into the churn, you will find authentic actors fighting against the greenwashing and green hushing efforts that are so apparently prevalent in today's business world.
Speaker AThere are dedicated champions working in corporate sustainability and one of those committed individuals is Lee Stewart.
Speaker AMy guest today on Global Warming is real.
Speaker ALee is the author of how to Build Sustainability into youo Business Strategy and has been in the trenches founding, leading and pushing other business leaders to think sincerely about sustainability.
Speaker ABeginning, in my opinion, by getting past that single word sustainability so often bandied about in marketing departments to the point of rendering it meaningless.
Speaker AAs he says, we've been talking about it for 20 years.
Speaker ASo much time spent touting your motivation as doing it for our children reflects a shadow of the tears streaking down the cheek of Cody Iron Ives.
Speaker ALee cringes when he hears yet another business person talk about doing it for our children.
Speaker AYeah, of course we are, he says.
Speaker AThat's a given.
Speaker AWhat are you doing?
Speaker AGet on with it.
Speaker AIt's enough talk.
Speaker ASadly, he says, I've gone to so many conferences where they'd say the same stuff 20 years ago.
Speaker AThe only difference is there's more people in the room.
Speaker ABut what are you actually going to do tomorrow?
Speaker ALee's mission is to get people from talking in rooms to taking authentic action in the real world.
Speaker AHis expertise in practical triple bottom line business practices spans decades and continents, working throughout Australia, the United Kingdom, Japan and New Zealand.
Speaker AHe's launched startups, consulted and served as head of sustainability for major corporations such as Fujitsu and Fonterra.
Speaker ALee launched ESG strategy in 2022 where he assists boards and senior leaders in developing their sustainability and ESG roadmaps.
Speaker AHe offers his services pro bono to the Kingdom of Tonga, a low lying island nation threatened with climate driven sea level rise, providing strategic advice on sustainability, circular economy and climate change.
Speaker ALee's insight and engaging style help us all understand how business, industry and civil society can get past the talk and the misdirection and the blame shifting to realize that sustainability and triple bottom line economics, people, planet profit, are in fact more than a marketing buzzword, but a worthwhile project in a crowded, climate changed world.
Speaker ALet's join our conversation as Lee and I get acquainted and get down to business.
Speaker BIn California in the Monterey Bay area.
Speaker CYep.
Speaker COh, were there fires there?
Speaker ANo.
Speaker BSo Monterey is about 120 miles south of San Francisco.
Speaker COkay.
Speaker CAll right.
Speaker BAnd the LA fires are farther south, but we've had our share of.
Speaker BNot, knock on wood, not so far this year, but we've had our share of fires around here.
Speaker CYeah, there was a big one here in 2019.
Speaker CWhere.
Speaker BThat's right, you guys have gotten.
Speaker CWhere it just felt like Sydney was under siege.
Speaker CYou could just.
Speaker CYou're watching this app and you're seeing the fires pop up and it was a ring of fire around Sydney.
Speaker CIt was for like a month.
Speaker BThere was one day In September of 2020, right before we moved.
Speaker BWe lived in San Francisco for nearly 30 years.
Speaker BAnd right before we moved down, we woke up one morning and the sky was orange.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BAnd it stayed that.
Speaker BIt was like midnight.
Speaker CIt's not eerie, isn't it?
Speaker BYeah, it's pretty strange.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BAnyway, yeah, it's good to talk to you.
Speaker BYou have quite a resume.
Speaker BSustainable business.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker CYeah, thanks.
Speaker BDo you want to walk us through just kind of a brief synopsis of your work and career?
Speaker CI grew up in New Zealand, so love for the outdoors.
Speaker CEnvironmental protection is part of who you are.
Speaker CGrowing up as a Kiwi, especially in the countryside a bit and, and most Kiwis, by the time you get 20, 21, you need to travel, you need to get out of the place.
Speaker CBecause we're quite small and traveling, you know, brought me to Australia, but also brought me around Southeast Asia.
Speaker CAnd I got to see firsthand how what humans are doing to the place.
Speaker CIt really, it wasn't good.
Speaker CAnd so I was sort of thinking, I had a good job in finance and telecommunications.
Speaker CI was thinking, oh, how do I re engineer myself to try and do good but still get paid well?
Speaker CBecause I still want to live well and I love travel and I've crafted my resume and to look at working in sustainability and corporate sustainability.
Speaker CI did startups for a number of years in the early 2000s where I develop online education around sustainability, e learning courses and so forth.
Speaker CAnd that sort of got me into all the conferences and I learned off so many great people.
Speaker CThere weren't any courses around then of what sustainability is.
Speaker CAnd I was very fortunate enough to land a corporate job.
Speaker CI had to swap my T shirt and jeans for the suit again because I got married and had a young family.
Speaker CSo the sort of lumpy cash flow of a start startup wasn't ideal.
Speaker CSo I had to suck it up.
Speaker CBut I was so fortunate.
Speaker CI got a role at Fujitsu, which is a global IT company, and was head of sustainability for New South Wales, and then got Oceania six months later.
Speaker CReally.
Speaker CAnd that was a lot of work around energy efficiency and data centers, but also looking at technology enablement.
Speaker CWhat could technology do to help reduce emissions, create better environmental outcomes?
Speaker CAnd really worked on some great projects where I helped environmental organizations find endangered species in the bush using early stages of AI and drones and things.
Speaker CThat was really cool.
Speaker CThen was in the global team, helped them get set net zero targets and renewable energy things and introduce all the frameworks and reporting and so forth and dealt with customers.
Speaker CThat was a real key issue where I was very different to other sustainability people I'd work with.
Speaker COur key clients, such as you might know, Qantas was one Australia post.
Speaker CWe all delivered big IT equipment to them.
Speaker CBut I would go in there and say, well, if you move to us, we'll reduce your emissions because our IT equipment's more efficient.
Speaker CPlus, here's your biggest emission sources say Qantas was jet fuel.
Speaker CIf you move away from pilots carrying all these 30 kg of flight manuals and they carry an iPad, what would that save you?
Speaker CAnd we worked out that 1kg of less weight on a plane was equivalent to $5,000 worth of jet fuel throughout the year.
Speaker AReally?
Speaker CReally?
Speaker CThat's so 30 kg of a pilot you stole days apart.
Speaker CWe're running with their manuals because they had.
Speaker CWhich plane am I on?
Speaker CWe all put that on an iPad.
Speaker CWe've got all the CASA approval, the aviation approval, so they could use it in the cockpit.
Speaker CAnd that saves them a few million dollars a year in fuel costs.
Speaker CSo it's those types of things which were really, really cool to work on.
Speaker CWhere you look at what's your customer's biggest problem?
Speaker CWhere can technology play a role?
Speaker CWhere can greater conversations happen around that?
Speaker CSo that was really cool.
Speaker CAnd then I worked in consulting for a bit that was really, really interesting.
Speaker CCause I really love the diversity of consulting.
Speaker CYou're jumping around different industries and things.
Speaker CAnd then sort of recently, just over five years ago, got tapped on the shoulder to go back to New Zealand to take up a role with Fonterra, which is big dairy, which is the largest.
Speaker CYeah, the largest company in New Zealand responsible roughly about half the emissions and methane cow methane was the big issue.
Speaker CSo, yeah, fortunate enough to work with some very smart people and help set up cross government industry fund to help with methane mitigation.
Speaker CWorked on some global bids and Nestle is a major customer and so forth.
Speaker CReally, really cool.
Speaker CGreat to go back to New Zealand for a few years, but then I decided it's time to go out of my own and I needed the headspace.
Speaker CSo I went and started my own consultancy, ESG Strategy, but set aside the year to finish my book, which I've just completed late last year.
Speaker CSo it's been quite good.
Speaker CI'm out on my own now.
Speaker CI'm sort of the chief virtual sustainment officer for three companies at the moment, like a large utility, a hotel chain in the PAC and a retailer.
Speaker CSo it's keeping me very interested and I'm looking to build a small team that does good things.
Speaker CReally.
Speaker BWhen you first started, was there a lot of pushback toward this?
Speaker CYeah, especially in Australia.
Speaker CThere's some analogies with the States.
Speaker CThere's sort of climate politics and stuff is just toxic.
Speaker CAustralia's coming out of what's almost 10 to 15 years of climate wars between opposition parties and so forth.
Speaker CSo the work I've had to do in the early stages and still sometimes now is disguised as energy efficiency, cost production and I don't really care what you call it, we're trying to make businesses do better.
Speaker CThe outcome is the same.
Speaker CIt's how you frame it.
Speaker CAnd how you frame it to the CFO is very different to the head of marketing, to the head of sales.
Speaker CSo it's those sort of things.
Speaker CSo we've had to disguise it quite well.
Speaker CWhen I look back on my career, I think one of my greatest achievements was keeping the title sustainability throughout those big climate wars and still dealing with large government clients.
Speaker CAnd it was quite hard at times.
Speaker CCause soon as you walk in the room, everyone knows your position, they know who you are.
Speaker CYeah, you've got a target.
Speaker CI feel like I got a target on my back.
Speaker BYeah, exactly.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker CThey all know, oh, here's the guy that's gonna.
Speaker BHere comes that sustainability guy.
Speaker CYeah, everyone here's a tree hugger.
Speaker CI'll make sure you recycle.
Speaker CHere's Lee.
Speaker CYou know all that stuff, it's just like, oh, cringy.
Speaker CYeah, but, but yeah, it's.
Speaker CYeah, it has been difficult.
Speaker CYou had to be a chameleon.
Speaker CI suppose that's probably why I describe it at certain Times, but keep your eye on the outcome, right?
Speaker CYes, eye on the outcome.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker CThat's the main thing.
Speaker BYeah, like, like you say, it's how you frame it.
Speaker BAnd you know, my thing is climate change, global warming.
Speaker BAnd I've, Yeah.
Speaker BLearned, I guess the hard way is if you can talk about it without even mentioning climate change, the C word.
Speaker CYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker BBecause you mentioned that, you know, here in the United States.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BEspecially now, we, we could talk about that, but let's not.
Speaker CYeah, yeah.
Speaker CWe've got better things to do, haven't we?
Speaker CYeah, right.
Speaker CMaybe.
Speaker BSo what's been the evolution of the sustainability, space and corporate adaptation?
Speaker CYeah, yeah.
Speaker CI think the evolutions come from the early stages of corporate social responsibility.
Speaker CLet's just make sure that we're not wrecking the planet.
Speaker COr if we are, let's try put some positive spin on it or get some NGO to help us, sort of send some money somewhere else to sort of COVID up the blackness and we can only disclose what we want to.
Speaker CWe can get away with it.
Speaker CYou've seen that evolution come to more standardized reporting.
Speaker CThe frameworks have helped really.
Speaker CWell, I think sometimes they go a bit too far because you end up reporting, you don't actually end up doing.
Speaker CSo that's one of the things where I think it needs some retraction back or it needs more investment because I talked to some of my colleagues in industry and all their budgets are on reporting and working with the finance teams to report.
Speaker CSo you've got the glossy sustainability report.
Speaker CAnd I've been in these organizations where I'm coming on 10 months later, I go, guys, what have you done?
Speaker CNothing.
Speaker CAnd I've got to scramble for a case study or something to, you know, I frame it as putting lipstick on a pig for another year, you know, trying to make it look good.
Speaker CSo that's a problem.
Speaker CBut the good thing I've seen is I was going to conferences where there might be 20 or 50 people.
Speaker CThere's now 800.
Speaker BOh, yeah, that's good.
Speaker CThat's a great thing in itself.
Speaker CI do have to bite my tongue a little bit when these people our age are suddenly going, oh, we should be doing this now.
Speaker CAnd I said, well, where were you 20, 30 years ago?
Speaker BExactly.
Speaker CBut I'm happy to.
Speaker CThey're encouraging and I'm sort of very encouragement of that.
Speaker CAnd that sort of one of the drivers for writing the book was to help those sort of people, you know, not make the same mistakes I did and go harder, faster.
Speaker CYeah, the evolution.
Speaker CI'm seeing now, unfortunately, I think we're going to an era of green hushing a little bit from what you mentioned in the States and even here in Australia.
Speaker CBut I'm confident that companies are getting on with it and are doing things.
Speaker CThey're going to miss out on some of the value because they're not going to be talking about it as openly and shouting from the rooftops a bit.
Speaker CBut I think that pause is actually going to be quite a good thing.
Speaker CI think in a year or two's time they'll be in a better position to start talking more openly about it and have confidence because they know they've been doing stuff.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd that gives me a strong encouragement.
Speaker BDo you think that green hushing might help, as you just described, help to mitigate greenwashing?
Speaker CAbsolutely.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CYeah, yeah.
Speaker CAnd the other sort of, when I look at that timeline, the good thing about social media has been we shine, but sunlight shines on it.
Speaker CYou can't get away with that photo, is that photo, that degradation of what you're doing, it becomes more transparent.
Speaker CSo you're going to have to front up to some of these issues that say, especially if your business is a large polluter, you're going to have to front up to it and say, yes, we know we are, but we're working on these things.
Speaker CWe're not perfect, but we're going to be working towards these things and we'll be reporting to you at least annually on our progress and our challenges.
Speaker CSo that's where the honesty and transparency is coming through and that helps with those GRI type frameworks and reporting and mandatory disclosure of climate risks and opportunities.
Speaker CAll that sort of legislation that's popping up all around the world is helping with that.
Speaker BWhat frameworks do you rely on?
Speaker BOr the best, I suppose the big.
Speaker COne that's coming across all around the world and I think even California's got something.
Speaker CIt's each individual country's interpretation of the Task Force for Climate Change.
Speaker CTCFD Task Force of Climate Change Financial Disclosures.
Speaker CThere's a whole lot of acronyms and I really hate them all.
Speaker CBut you can have a conversation with a Stalin person and just speak in acronyms and then you mix that with my IT background, you have total Alphabet soup, right?
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CIn Australia and in New Zealand they've adapted that to their framework and it's called Australian Sustainability Reporting Standards or Climate Related Disclosures.
Speaker CBut essentially what that means is if countries around the world and the EU are adopting, this is where companies need to disclose their climate Risks and opportunities and a generic kind of way with a process and it needs to go to the board level.
Speaker CAnd then in Australia you need to know what your carbon emissions are.
Speaker CSo I've just quickly.
Speaker CScope one is generally what you burn and fuel coal and so forth.
Speaker CScope two is the electricity that you use and like in Australia's a lot of coal fired power stations and stuff.
Speaker CSo there's a carbon element to every kilowatt of energy you use.
Speaker CSo that's what we need to report on now coming in this financial year, for next financial year and in the subsequent years, you're going to have to report on scope three, which is the emissions in your supply chain up and downstream.
Speaker CSo I've had to do some of that work as where you open up a whole Pandora's box where how many suppliers do you have?
Speaker CDo they have climate targets of their own?
Speaker CDo we get our targets?
Speaker CAnother one is sbti, Science Based Target Initiative.
Speaker CDo we have them accredited to that?
Speaker CWhich means you've got to go look at your Scope three.
Speaker CYou've got to go through a rigorous process.
Speaker CSo there are numerous frameworks out there, there.
Speaker CBut the one probably going to hit even smaller companies is that climate related disclosures because it'll force the large companies to look in their supply chain and ask questions.
Speaker CAnd I'm doing that for my clients right now, asking suppliers very pointy questions that some of them just don't know how to answer and they've got to have to get up to speed reasonably quickly if they want to actually keep supplying to the big guys.
Speaker CSo that's what I'm seeing now.
Speaker BThat must be really a complex process getting the scope 3.
Speaker BNow did you develop the triple C framework?
Speaker CYeah, sorry to throw another framework out there, but I wanted to just come up with the simplest one.
Speaker CAnd this follows the three parts to my book.
Speaker CAnd this is if you're new to sustainability or you want to test what your strategy is and what your thinking is.
Speaker CAnd I peeled it down when all the tough conversation I've had could have been made simpler if I just followed this simple process.
Speaker CNow the three Cs stand for confidence, commitment and consistency.
Speaker CAnd when I've jumped to one other too fast, I realize, oh, I haven't spent more time there.
Speaker CSo when I talk about confidence, this is having an understanding of the global macro issues.
Speaker CClimate change, diversity, inclusion, modern slavery, waste.
Speaker CWhat are all these big global issues and what does actually mean to your business?
Speaker CAre they relevant or not?
Speaker CBut you've got to have an understanding of what they basically are.
Speaker CAnd also it'll force you to have a look in your supply chain as well.
Speaker CSo if you're a large polluter, obviously climate change is an issue or waste.
Speaker CIf you work in communities, you know that sort of areas need a focus as well.
Speaker CSo where I found, I've tried to go to a board to set a climate target and they didn't even know what a carbon was.
Speaker CThat's one of my biggest failures.
Speaker CAnd you just spin your wheels and you have these political debates, these ethical debates and so forth.
Speaker CAnd I'm going, oh, I didn't spend time with the confidence.
Speaker CI need to just go to carbon 101.
Speaker CI need to lay the breadcrumbs towards this big decision.
Speaker CSo they weren't confident.
Speaker CSo that's really, really, really important.
Speaker CAnd that's the first section I book, which is covers off those at a very high level.
Speaker CThe next part is the commitment and that's looking at what matters most to your business.
Speaker CDo you need to set things like a climate target, waste targets, anything around community or engagement?
Speaker CWhat are you actually going to stand for?
Speaker CWhat matters most to your business?
Speaker CThere's some good frameworks, again, sustainable development goals.
Speaker CLooking at those, there's a materiality assessment which you should do, which is going out asking people, what do you think are our number top three or four things that we should focus on?
Speaker CAsk your people, customers, even NGOs, even governments.
Speaker CI've done that.
Speaker CAnd then try really focus on three or four core things.
Speaker CMost companies will come up with something like climate change, our people, community, maybe governance.
Speaker CThose are sort of the generic ones.
Speaker CAnd then the final bit is the consistency.
Speaker CAnd that's where I see so many companies let themselves down, where they will come out with a great sustainability report some targets and go, hey, we're all good.
Speaker CAnd then John or Amy has moved on from the company resting on one person, who is this token sustainability person and it falls all apart, you know.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CSo the consistency is the governance model, who's responsible, what executives or what functions of the business are going to be responsible for.
Speaker CAnd hopefully that sustainability person, the organization, is more a coordinator, not the doer of everything and is making sure that everyone does that and the responsibilities are dispersed amongst from the leadership team down.
Speaker CSo that's the, that's the crux of it.
Speaker CAnd if you follow that, you're in pretty good stead to make sure that you, you know, you avoid greenwashing, you have consistency and you have something that's relevant to your business.
Speaker CWhen done Properly, it becomes a competitive advantage for you.
Speaker CIt's not a cost.
Speaker BTalk about that.
Speaker BTalk about how this is a competitive advantage for businesses.
Speaker CYeah, exactly.
Speaker CWell, one of the things is if what I mentioned before, companies, especially if you supply a larger company, if they're going to be forced by this regulation or if they want to set science based targets, they're going to have to choose suppliers that are lower carbon over time.
Speaker CSo if you have all your stuff together and you have a program in place to look at that, that's going to be more competitive when they go to select you versus someone El it won't be just price, it'll be on what's the carbon component of your product or service and can you help us reduce ours.
Speaker CSo that's really important.
Speaker CThe other times I've really worked at is helping create a competitive advantage.
Speaker CWhen you're looking at the sales, working with your salespeople and understanding where money comes into your business, what are your customers trying to grapple with?
Speaker CCan you support them in some of these big challenges?
Speaker CBecause when I've been as head of sustainability, large multinational, I would love it when suppliers came to me and said hey Lee, I know you've got this climate target, can we have a chat?
Speaker CBecause I've got an idea and it's a very easy idea.
Speaker CI haven't really been rejected on any one of the calls.
Speaker CJust want to have a chat around sustainability how we could probably work together on something.
Speaker CI've designed new products, new offerings together with suppliers that have grown market share.
Speaker CSo that's the real competitive advantage is something that's really undervalued in sustainability.
Speaker CAnd this is where I see it.
Speaker CWhen it's truly stuck sticks is when it helps drive revenue for businesses exist to make money.
Speaker ARight.
Speaker CWhen you align sustainably with the money making process of your company, it's, it has longevity and it's not something that gets chucked out when the budgets are tied.
Speaker CIt's something becomes core of the business.
Speaker CSo that's looking for those opportunities is key.
Speaker BSounds like you know, people, businesses, business leaders will come charging in and yeah, let's do something about it.
Speaker AAnd then.
Speaker CYep.
Speaker BAnd it kind of, yeah.
Speaker CThe worst thing I said, oh, I'm really passionate about this.
Speaker CWell that's great.
Speaker CMake sure that passion comes into a framework with accountability and it's not resting on one or two people in your organization to be passionate.
Speaker BYou know, how often do you encounter, and I imagine that you'd be able to sniff this out pretty fast, people that say yeah, we want to do something about it, but it's just a marketing ploy to please their customers.
Speaker BI guess that's greenwashing.
Speaker CBut the first things that I look for is, do you have someone responsible for sustainability?
Speaker CWhere does that person sit?
Speaker CIt sits under marketing hr.
Speaker CIt's probably, yeah, probably not great.
Speaker CYou have a look at if they're trying to push.
Speaker CA lot of companies will try to push, hey, this product's sustainable, right?
Speaker CWe've got this new offering, servicing.
Speaker COkay, what gives you the right to talk about that product?
Speaker CWhat are you doing from a company's perspective?
Speaker CHas your company set a climate target?
Speaker CHas your company got a governance model around sustainability?
Speaker COr have you just come up with this one product that you think is going to solve all the problems?
Speaker CBecause if you haven't sorted out your own backyard first, I don't think you have the right to go out there and spruce your sustainment credentials of a product or service.
Speaker CAnd you can be found out very quickly within five minutes.
Speaker CI could go, right.
Speaker CBut I don't throw it out straight away.
Speaker CI go, here's the opportunity for you.
Speaker CAnd I'm sat on many times.
Speaker CI'm going to play, say, a Greenpeace activist and you pitch this market to me and these are the five things I'll shoot you down with.
Speaker CBut guess what?
Speaker CYou can fix those relatively quickly if you have the desire to do so.
Speaker CAnd it might be in a few months time, you could launch that product because you've got the credibility to do that, because you've looked internally, your backyard's in order, or maybe not totally in order, but you're getting towards that and you can talk about what you're doing.
Speaker CYeah, so that's my key thing is I don't want to discourage these innovations, but make sure you're standing on the right platform to talk about it.
Speaker CTo start with, do you ever appeal personally to leaders?
Speaker BLike, what sort of a world do you want to leave your children kind of.
Speaker BKind of approach?
Speaker BOr is that a little over the top for context?
Speaker CIt works in some context, but I think it's been done for 20 years.
Speaker CAnd I cringe when I hear a leader say, it's all about five children.
Speaker CI go, yeah, of course we are.
Speaker CThat's given.
Speaker CWhat are you doing?
Speaker CGet on with it.
Speaker CDon't.
Speaker CI mean, it's enough talk.
Speaker CAnd sadly, I've gone to so many conferences where I think you said the same stuff 20 years ago.
Speaker CThe only difference is there's more people in a room.
Speaker CBut what are you actually going to do tomorrow?
Speaker CRight.
Speaker AAll right.
Speaker CFor your children.
Speaker CThat's a great motivator.
Speaker CIt's a great motivator for me.
Speaker CIt's kept me going through some very dark times writing a book and the careers are going, oh, what am I doing this for?
Speaker CI could earn more money doing something else.
Speaker CI could have a better lifestyle.
Speaker CBut Jesus, I need to keep going with this because of the legacy, because we don't have an option.
Speaker CAnd that's ingrained in most sustainably, people I work with.
Speaker CBut it's.
Speaker CYeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker BI've been writing about climate change for about 20 years now.
Speaker BAnd so I remember 20 years ago.
Speaker BYou know, the time is short.
Speaker BWe've got to do something now it's 20 years later.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker CIt's shorter.
Speaker BWhat have we done?
Speaker BDo you by any chance know of Scott Pointon?
Speaker CNo, I don't.
Speaker COkay.
Speaker BThe reason not.
Speaker BI was going to say he's Australian.
Speaker BThat doesn't mean you should know him.
Speaker BHe's Australian, but he's the founder of the Rainforests Trust, right?
Speaker CYep.
Speaker BAnd he's based in Switzerland now.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BAnd the reason I, I bring this up, we're.
Speaker BI was just chatting with him earlier today and he was talking about conferences and.
Speaker BYeah, a lot of talk and no doing.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BWhat was his.
Speaker BWas his.
Speaker CYeah, yeah.
Speaker CSo I've got a couple of conferences come out where I'm asked to speak and I've just talked them into turning into a workshop.
Speaker BThat sounds like a good idea.
Speaker BYeah, I suppose it.
Speaker BJust talking at people.
Speaker BYou're talking.
Speaker CHere's a one page worksheet and you're gonna fill us out as I talk and you're gonna go back to your business tomorrow and ask these questions and you're gonna choose two things you're gonna change in the next month, you know.
Speaker CExcellent.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BI mean, here's stuff to do and you have a ton.
Speaker BYou got a month to do it.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd it could be as simple as the basic one, you recycle better.
Speaker COr it could be you have a conversation with the guy or girl that manages the largest source of your emissions and ask them, what can we do to help you?
Speaker CYeah, just get off yet.
Speaker BJust basically get on, get on the.
Speaker CFloor, walk the floors, you know, do something.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd learn.
Speaker CLearn by seeing for yourself.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BYou worked with the kingdom of Tonga, is that correct?
Speaker CYes.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BAnd what is it they became the world's first circular kingdom.
Speaker COh, we're working towards that, correct?
Speaker CNo, we're working towards it.
Speaker CWorking pro bono.
Speaker CWith the lovely people of tonga for last five or six years, and was one of the advisors that COP28 in Dubai as well.
Speaker CAnd just going there and spending time and time at their landfill was their main issue.
Speaker CThere's no infrastructure for recycling and.
Speaker CAnd countries love to donate to the Pacific islands.
Speaker CSo they donate them with plastic balers and crushers and stuff, which all work, which is great, but there's nowhere for it to go.
Speaker CYou can bail up plastic, you can crush it, but you got to ship it somewhere because there's no.
Speaker BIt's the infrastructure.
Speaker CSo I've just gone, well, we need to design better.
Speaker CAnd there's papers going into parliament soon about trying to get serious funding to actually turn some of that shredded plastic into jewelry and have a local social enterprise.
Speaker CSo what we're going to do is going to be led by local women of working with the universities here in Australia.
Speaker CI can't say which one because it's close, but where they've got it in a container ship where they can shred plastic and turn it straight into 3D filament for printing.
Speaker CSo they will print a sort of outline of a whale tail, which be finished off by hand painted by locals and sold to everyone that comes to swim with the whales in Tonga.
Speaker AOh, really?
Speaker CSo we're trying to create a circular economy that way and a social enterprise that gives jobs and women leadership roles in the Pacific.
Speaker CAnd if that model works, we will have these containers go out to some of the other islands so we can actually start harvesting the plastic, doing something.
Speaker CSo turning that into a resource.
Speaker CSo that's the vision for that idea.
Speaker AThat's great.
Speaker CBut, you know, Tonga is the second most impacted country in the world by climate change.
Speaker CI've seen firsthand things like burial grounds being washed away.
Speaker CIt's heartbreaking to see what's going on.
Speaker CAnd then it was an honor to be part of their delegation at COP Dubai a few years ago.
Speaker CAnd just to see that delegation just outnumbered by the US and eu and they're bustling and hustling, and there's the king of Tonga prime minister trying to help get them to their area where they need to be.
Speaker CAnd it's, you know, koa and stuff.
Speaker CAnd just.
Speaker CAnd I just wanted to scream out, these guys are the reason why we're all here, and they need a better stage.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd.
Speaker CAnd just.
Speaker CAnd so there's lots of work to do for them.
Speaker CAnd that's kind of my purpose has been finding that, okay, yes, I do work and I get paid reasonably well, but I'm using that to help a nation survive and doing my best I can.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker CSo that's the thing that really keeps me going.
Speaker CHas been a fantastic journey so far and there's more to come.
Speaker CThere's a lot more coming there.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BWhat are your feelings now on of the COP process?
Speaker COh, you've only been to one.
Speaker CIt's a hard one.
Speaker CThe Dubai one was hard because there were a lot of fossil fuel lobbyists there.
Speaker BExactly, yeah.
Speaker CI do think, and I heard countries like New Zealand and Australia sort of bag it out and not go there.
Speaker CBut it is a trade show and a connection place more than anything else.
Speaker CIt is the opportunity to connect.
Speaker CAnd that week I was there, I had bilateral meetings with seven or eight countries and they weren't arranged.
Speaker CBut you walked and hustled and this guy, you know, and you went in there and you got to the us, Canada, uk and you did that.
Speaker CAnd it was just an amazing experience to see that everyone's there on a.
Speaker CGenerally on a common purpose and it's just that face to face connections, the randomness of it and throwing everything together and good stuff happens.
Speaker CSo it does have a bad rap because a lot of talk fests and stuff, but it's what happens on the edges, the human connections, especially all the people in their traditional dress seeing it, it was just amazing.
Speaker CWalking around, you would see 15 African, South American, Pacific, North American.
Speaker CIt's just an amazing boiling pot of humanity trying to do the right thing.
Speaker CSo it's not the main stage, it's around the edges where I think a lot of the real stuff is done.
Speaker BI was able to do two cops, cop 15 and cop 21 and 15 was back in 2009 and that didn't go so well.
Speaker BBut I have to say COP21, that's the one moment in this whole journey of me being concerned about climate change where I felt, oh, wow, the world is coming together.
Speaker BThere was real feelings, it was all aspirational and we can talk about what's happened since then.
Speaker BBut that was a great moment, I thought, back in 2020.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd I do need to remind people when they say that I think, what, up to 160, 190 countries agreed on something.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker CWhen does that ever happen?
Speaker CIt's a solid foundation and yes, there's been disappointments and we need to do more.
Speaker CBut I to remind myself that that's quite significant what happened.
Speaker BYou're involved with AI technology and sustainability.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker BCan you talk a little bit about that?
Speaker CYeah, I'M using it to help with working with the customer journey that I do.
Speaker CSo I use it to interrogate their competitors, their own public information.
Speaker CAnd I've developed a query quick scorecard based on the framework I spoke about on the book and what they do and the policies and so forth.
Speaker CSo that's really helped streamline my time to be more effective because every customer I work with wants to know how they're doing relative to their competitors.
Speaker CSo it's quite easy to do a quick scan of that.
Speaker CWhere I'm helping with and some people in my team I work with helping with is carbon accounting and measurement.
Speaker CI think that's a huge growth area where we can streamline a lot of that energy efficiency scenario analysis.
Speaker CThere's quite a lot of opportunities there to look with AI and even work with some of the universities.
Speaker CThere are 3D printing cities and then projecting onto them what 1, 2, 3, 4 degrees looks like and showing how the city.
Speaker CSo that's looking really good.
Speaker CSo the visual aspects of that is really amazing.
Speaker CThe type of stuff you do so largely untap that potential for good.
Speaker CDefinitely there's a long way to go.
Speaker CBut if you were starting a software business right now around climate change and sustainability, you're probably better off just starting from scratch and using the tools available to scale quickly.
Speaker CSo that's quite exciting, the possibilities there.
Speaker BYeah, it really is.
Speaker BThe opportunities of AI.
Speaker BThere's obviously a discussion around AI, the good, the bad, the ugly, whatever.
Speaker BBut I think if you approach it as a tool.
Speaker CYep.
Speaker BWith a good purpose in mind as opposed to putting out AI slop or something.
Speaker CYeah, yeah.
Speaker CAnd I treat it like a intelligent coworker.
Speaker CSo I've trained my little tool up.
Speaker CIt's got my whole book in there, it's got all the policies I've written for other clients, it's got my knowledge base and I can interrogate it and sort of help me with that.
Speaker CSo it helps me be more effective and create a bigger impact.
Speaker CSo that's where I treat it like an intelligent co worker that still needs a little help a lot.
Speaker BBut yeah, so say there's a businessman that hasn't really been thinking too much about sustainability, but he's.
Speaker BYou know what, I should do something about this.
Speaker BWhat would you.
Speaker BFirst off, I'm sure to buy your book, be the first thing.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker BBut what is your advice for business leaders that want to get more active in this space?
Speaker CJust first of all, look at your backyard a little bit and you can do this on a back of a You know, page just write down where you think your biggest impacts are of your operations.
Speaker CSo could it be the amount of emissions waste you work in communities?
Speaker CJust list all these down and especially if you're in a larger organization, maybe have a chat to the guys that look at that.
Speaker CWhat are they doing around energy efficiency or reductions around that?
Speaker CJust understand that landscape a bit better and from there you might find two or three core things and then probably just research.
Speaker CSo if you've got a long supply chain that goes to say developing nations, you might want to understand a bit more about modern slavery, what's going on there.
Speaker CIf you're a large polluter and you create a lot of waste, you might want to understand what's the global issues around plastics and the oceans and other things.
Speaker CDo I contribute to that?
Speaker CSo you have that sort of framing and that confidence piece.
Speaker CFrom there you should be able to try and understand what you're already doing because I bet most organizations are doing some stuff already which is great and is there an opportunity to bring that in under overarching strategy where you get more benefit from that.
Speaker CSo you might have a classic example.
Speaker CI work with a large retailer, it's got 100 odd stores and store is doing some great stuff around recycling.
Speaker CLet's share it with everyone else you know.
Speaker CSo let's bring those stories to life and don't be afraid to start telling those stories internally which you'll be encouraged by what comes out from your own team.
Speaker CThere'll be a lot of people that were thinking about this and going oh now I've got a vehicle, I've got these ideas.
Speaker CSo harness your team is a really, really untapped resource.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BWould you say you might have already addressed this but more of an acceptance, taking sustainability seriously in the business world?
Speaker CYeah, definitely.
Speaker CAnd the key, probably the next step for what I do for that bit is look where your customers are, where does your money come in and what do they care about?
Speaker CThey might have a published sustainability report, your largest customers.
Speaker CSo have a read of those.
Speaker CSo that's where you can align your vision or your sustainability strategy to be climate customer centric.
Speaker CAnd don't be afraid to go and ask your key customers if you're new to sustainability, say oh you've got a sustainability report.
Speaker CHow do you go about it as a supplier to you?
Speaker CWhat do you want to see from us so you can co create your sustainability strategy in line with your clients needs and wants.
Speaker CAnd that is a very powerful conversation.
Speaker CIt's not you trying to push more product or services down there, it's you collaborating genuinely on a mutual global issue and that reaps huge rewards over time.
Speaker BI think authenticity is key.
Speaker BIf you were to have the ear of government leaders, what would you tell them that we need right now?
Speaker COh dear.
Speaker CWe just need consistency and get out of the way.
Speaker BYeah, I like that.
Speaker CAustralia's got three year terms, you know, it's not long enough.
Speaker CYou need to sit down and sort out the energy policy and don't touch it for a decade and let industry take its place.
Speaker CDon't just flip flop stuff on these core issues and seriously, get out of the way.
Speaker BThat's a frustrating thing here in the U.S. you know, we're in the Paris agreement, we're out of the Paris agreement.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CAnd for me, from the other side of the world, we've been here before, California's still in and then we look at all the other states they're still in and it's good and it's sad how it's become that way.
Speaker CBut I think at the core we all want a better future.
Speaker CEven when I talk to the most climate skeptic farmers in my last role in New Zealand, they want to leave their farm in a better condition than they got it for the next generation.
Speaker CSo it's that, it's that.
Speaker CAnd I think if I step back a little bit, the climate movement that you and I have been a part of is guilty of selling doom and fear too much that we can turn people off.
Speaker CBut I like to sell here's a positive future vision, you know, and the core, I don't think anyone wants to leave the world a worse place.
Speaker BI don't think so.
Speaker BAnd I agree that there's been too much doom and gloom and too much, you know, talking over people's heads and not, not finding people where they are and addressing.
Speaker CA chat.
Speaker BYeah, yeah, yeah, just having a chat.
Speaker CExactly.
Speaker BAnd this has been a great chat.
Speaker CYeah, it's been awesome.
Speaker BSo tell us about your book.
Speaker BSo we want to make sure that.
Speaker APeople know about your book.
Speaker CSo the book is how to build sustainability into your business strategy.
Speaker CI wrote it for business leaders and it's in business speak.
Speaker CIt's not sort of from the tree hugging angle.
Speaker CIt's practical business guide of what you can do, look at your business and how you can use sustainability as a competitive advantage.
Speaker CSo ideally you can read it in a weekend, ask questions in your business, Monday, Tuesday and by Friday, hey, you might have done something for good and you've been excellent.
Speaker AI may have on occasion been guilty of, as Lee Stewart says, selling fear and doom.
Speaker AIt's hard not to be profoundly concerned about the future of our species, the world we built, and the fate of life on the planet.
Speaker AIt's all heady stuff.
Speaker AIf I say that hope is when we stop fooling ourselves, as I often do, it means there's still hope.
Speaker ATo put put another way, we can maintain hope not by deceiving ourselves, but by taking practical steps to incorporate social and environmental business strategies with the notion that we're all in this together.
Speaker AIf we all pick up our trash, every sector, every CEO, every citizen, will each one be better for it?
Speaker ACheck the Show Notes to find out more about Lee Stewart's work, the circular economy and the triple bottom line.
Speaker ABusiness leaders looking for a real world practical guide should check out his best selling book, how to build Sustainability into your business Strategy.
Speaker AA practical, no nonsense business guide.
Speaker AYou know the drill.
Speaker AIf you like what we're doing, please like and subscribe to the podcast.
Speaker AAnd if you can spare a dollar or two, feel free to leave us a tip to help keep us going.
Speaker AWe would definitely appreciate that.
Speaker AThanks for listening and we'll see you next time on Global Warming is Real.
Speaker AThere's always more we can do to stop climate change.
Speaker ANo amount of engagement is too little.
Speaker AAnd now more than ever, your involvement matters.
Speaker ATo learn more and do more, visitors globalwarmingisreal.com thanks for listening.
Speaker AI'm your host, Tom Schueneman.
Speaker AWe'll see you next time on Global Warming Is Real.